Categories Education
11 districts data; ~100k
in person school
Aug to Oct 2020
NC had 1-2 cases per 1k pop (that's brisk)
733 community acq cases
If schools' transmission mirrored the state
Expected 800+ cases in school
Actual:
32 in school transmissions
Thoughts
[thread]

I really don't know what to say
America has few opportunities for kids who are born poor, school has long been one of them
Other countries recognize that schools provide upward mobility, detect child abuse, provide a hot meal, educate kids, allow them to develop socially
While the European union has bent over backwards to open schools, in the US we have seen massive school opposition
The schools that are open are not based on scientific factors (rate of transmission/ hospitalization), but by political factors (do they hate trump - close; strong unions - closed)
The mantra used is that schools are a threat to kids and teachers
Recently the Swedish experience came out and that showed that schools are remarkably safe
It showed incredibly low risks to students and teachers from open schools (without even
REAL data on schools from Sweden
— Dr. Vinay Prasad MD MPH, Associate Professor (@VPrasadMDMPH) January 7, 2021
Schools open Mar-June
2 mil kids
No MASK
Soc distancing
No HVAC renos
No change in death for kids
15 -> ICU
0 deaths from COVID
RR of being teacher & requiring ICU for covid
= 1.10 (95% confidence interval [CI], 0.49 to 2.49
[thread] pic.twitter.com/5AzhceIFGL

2/ https://t.co/btxlm8CSZG
‘.. a group of UK academics who work with children and adolescents. … concerned about the lack of focus on the needs of this age group … in policy making during the pandemic. We provide scientific evidence that might help to redress this imbalance.’
3/ .@DrHelenDodd wrote about the importance of f2f play: ‘Without the opportunity to play closely with peers, children can feel lonely and socially isolated, which is linked to short- and long-term mental health
4/ .@utafrith wrote on the impact of children missing school: https://t.co/IY4JHnCiAK
Conclusion: ‘The consequences of a large gap in schooling are waiting to be documented and these effects will occupy social services and mental health specialists for many years to come.’
5/ .@sjblakemore Highlighted the impact on teenagers. ‘Research … has demonstrated the crucial importance of social interaction and social learning in adolescence, which is a sensitive period of social brain development.’
🧵 1/
Thinking about ways to translate what I am doing at school into everyday words, and wonder if anyone would be interested in me trying to tweet some of my readings this year?
— Heather Morgan (she/her)\U0001f469\u200d\U0001f9bc\U0001f3f3\ufe0f\u200d\U0001f308 \U0001f1e8\U0001f1e6 (@poweredbylove2) January 3, 2021
I don't I can get them into single tweets, but if folks were interested I'd try 4 short synoptic threads.
In the study of the theology of the church McGrath notes two ways of viewing the church, both of which are problematic if 'belonging' is our goal. The first view is of purity and the second an idea of a 'mixed body' of sinners and saints.
2/
In the purity model, cohesion/acceptance are based on a person's commitment to a narrowly prescribed list of rules/requirements. Succeed at keeping these rules and you can stay. Otherwise, you will need to be put 'out' because your failure risks the purity of the Church & u.
3/
Those churches most concerned with keeping out (LGBTQ, women in ministry, whatever) are most likely to adhere to a purity model of church (and although this goes beyond purity culture, it's part of where that idea comes from).
4/
The search/drive for purity creates evermore insular groups of individuals to the point where one church in our city is convinced that in a city of 74 churches the only Christian's in the city are the 17 that attend their church.
5/
We're all ready for @GavinWilliamson's statement (due at 1pm but the PM is running late a little bit). We'll be tweeting updates. Here's a taster of what's potentially on the menu ... https://t.co/Et78NTDQGq
— Schools Week (@SchoolsWeek) January 6, 2021
.@GavinWilliamson says this isn't a decision the government wanted to take. 'Our schools have not suddenly become unsafe, but limiting attendance essential when Covid rates are climbing'
He will set out the contingency plans he'd 'prepared but hoped to have never implemented'
'We're far better placed to cope with disruption than last march', Williamson adds we're better at delivering online learning and they will support parents
Williamson says if parents feel they aren't getting suitable remote education they they should raise concerns first with the headteacher, and "failing that report the matter to Ofsted".
Ofsted will inspect schools where it has concerns