Categories Society
7 days
30 days
All time
Recent
Popular
Since it is a lovely peaceful Saturday morning, I clearly have to rectify that. Therefore: the World Rugby Transgender Policy and Nye Bevan.
Thread.
This is the WR policy, and explanation by Ross Tucker, who was part of the Working Group. I presented to the Workshop in February on liability, but wasnât part of the Working Group itself. Itâs worth reading this before going further.
And this is the statue of Nye Bevan in Cardiff. Anyone who goes to matches in Cardiff knows it. Itâs right by the Castle; more importantly, itâs right by the Rummer. Please God, weâll get back to see it on a match day soon.
However, what I'm talking about here isn't his comment that he learnt everything he needed to know about politics by dealing with rugby committees, but the one that made the title of the last decent Manic Street Preachers album:
"This is my truth, tell me yours."
What has struck me in the debate/flame-war over the proposed policy is that a large part of this is conflicting truths.
I know that sounds impossible. The truth is the truth is the truth, right? There can only be one truth, not truths, right?
Wrong. Here's why.
Thread.
This is the WR policy, and explanation by Ross Tucker, who was part of the Working Group. I presented to the Workshop in February on liability, but wasnât part of the Working Group itself. Itâs worth reading this before going further.
The World Rugby Transgender guideline is now out, and fully available here: https://t.co/RUZ7QrlodQ You\u2019ll also find a document called FAQs which tries to answer some common questions. We firmly believe it is the right thing in an emotive issue, for many reasons.
— Ross Tucker (@Scienceofsport) October 9, 2020
And this is the statue of Nye Bevan in Cardiff. Anyone who goes to matches in Cardiff knows it. Itâs right by the Castle; more importantly, itâs right by the Rummer. Please God, weâll get back to see it on a match day soon.
However, what I'm talking about here isn't his comment that he learnt everything he needed to know about politics by dealing with rugby committees, but the one that made the title of the last decent Manic Street Preachers album:
"This is my truth, tell me yours."
What has struck me in the debate/flame-war over the proposed policy is that a large part of this is conflicting truths.
I know that sounds impossible. The truth is the truth is the truth, right? There can only be one truth, not truths, right?
Wrong. Here's why.
Wages for housework: my grandmother did all of the typing for decades and this is how people talk about her đ
âJames would have documents typed, annotate them, and then dispatch them to comrades around the world for political discussion and feedback.â
I ran out of characters but her name is Selma James.
âHave the letters typedâ like the typists and their donât matter. In a Marxist discussion. Good god.
Anyway you can see in this milieu of watching her husband be vaunted as a theorist while she was his main intellectual partner and making his work possible while also not being acknowledged that she first formulated the need for a Wages for Housework campaign.
Their labor*
Iâm so annoyed!!
âBut he wrote the Black Jacobins when she was still a kidâ yes but as the interview notes, he came back to it for multiple editions and *someone* was typing his documents
Selma James was the someone. The typist had a name, a life, and an intellect of her own.
âJames would have documents typed, annotate them, and then dispatch them to comrades around the world for political discussion and feedback.â
I ran out of characters but her name is Selma James.
âHave the letters typedâ like the typists and their donât matter. In a Marxist discussion. Good god.
Anyway you can see in this milieu of watching her husband be vaunted as a theorist while she was his main intellectual partner and making his work possible while also not being acknowledged that she first formulated the need for a Wages for Housework campaign.
Their labor*
Iâm so annoyed!!
I ran out of characters but her name is Selma James.
— \U0001f1e7\U0001f1e7 Ethereal Bisexual Chanda Prescod-Weinstein (@IBJIYONGI) January 5, 2021
\u201cHave the letters typed\u201d like the typists and their don\u2019t matter. In a Marxist discussion. Good god.
âBut he wrote the Black Jacobins when she was still a kidâ yes but as the interview notes, he came back to it for multiple editions and *someone* was typing his documents
Selma James was the someone. The typist had a name, a life, and an intellect of her own.
Leavers beginning to realise EU states see EU *fundamentally* differently from how Leavers see it. THREAD 1/9
Some Leavers believe UKâs economic/political interests/qualities are fundamentally different from France & Germany. But this is so daft & so close to obvious extreme nationalism it never explained the EUâs existence for them 2/
But if UK isnât fundamentally different from Germany & France. How to make sense of German / French EU membership? 3/
One Leaver coping strategy was âEU is bad idea for all EU statesâ, just they havenât realised yet (not as clever as Brits ssh) and their bad establishments are suppressing bold independence movements 4/
But hoped-for Brexit copycats havenât arrived. Greece seems determined to stay even as its economy improves. Anti-EU forces donât win, or win but donât try and leave. Remember how Hungary & Poland were going to back UK? Anyone? 5/
How it How it\u2019s
— Simon Cox (@SimonFRCox) December 10, 2020
started going pic.twitter.com/nOHaFj2377
Some Leavers believe UKâs economic/political interests/qualities are fundamentally different from France & Germany. But this is so daft & so close to obvious extreme nationalism it never explained the EUâs existence for them 2/
But if UK isnât fundamentally different from Germany & France. How to make sense of German / French EU membership? 3/
One Leaver coping strategy was âEU is bad idea for all EU statesâ, just they havenât realised yet (not as clever as Brits ssh) and their bad establishments are suppressing bold independence movements 4/
But hoped-for Brexit copycats havenât arrived. Greece seems determined to stay even as its economy improves. Anti-EU forces donât win, or win but donât try and leave. Remember how Hungary & Poland were going to back UK? Anyone? 5/
Since everyone is writing abt Julian Assange today, some posts:
The Growing WikiLeaks Conspiracy [Indictment]
https://t.co/i3dNE6lnl7
This talks about the superseding CFAA charge that Assange boosters are generally silent or worse about.
Three Inconvenient Truths about a Hypothetical Trump Pardon for Julian Assange
https://t.co/FDl2KMJV8x
1) It may not work
2) It would have to pardon other crimes
3) That would include Trump's own corruption
Rat-Fucker Rashomon: Getting the "Highest Level of Government" to Free Julian Assange
https://t.co/oNr8YgXbhk
On the pardon discussions with Trump that WikiLeaks doesn't want you to know about.
The Minh Quang Pham Precedent to the Julian Assange Extradition
https://t.co/1i7yErl0sC
The UK extradited a guy whose primary crime (at the time) was doing graphic design for AQAP.
Julian Assange's First Witness, Journalism Professor Mark Feldstein, Professes to Be Unfamiliar with the Public Record on Assange
https://t.co/sl0sasWgeu
WikiLeaks boosters are lying, cynically, abt what changed between 2013 and 2017.
The Growing WikiLeaks Conspiracy [Indictment]
https://t.co/i3dNE6lnl7
This talks about the superseding CFAA charge that Assange boosters are generally silent or worse about.
Three Inconvenient Truths about a Hypothetical Trump Pardon for Julian Assange
https://t.co/FDl2KMJV8x
1) It may not work
2) It would have to pardon other crimes
3) That would include Trump's own corruption
Rat-Fucker Rashomon: Getting the "Highest Level of Government" to Free Julian Assange
https://t.co/oNr8YgXbhk
On the pardon discussions with Trump that WikiLeaks doesn't want you to know about.
The Minh Quang Pham Precedent to the Julian Assange Extradition
https://t.co/1i7yErl0sC
The UK extradited a guy whose primary crime (at the time) was doing graphic design for AQAP.
Julian Assange's First Witness, Journalism Professor Mark Feldstein, Professes to Be Unfamiliar with the Public Record on Assange
https://t.co/sl0sasWgeu
WikiLeaks boosters are lying, cynically, abt what changed between 2013 and 2017.