BC HEALTH
Saved by @Alex1Powell

Q: Why do we use a stethoscope?
A: For many reasons, and here’s one of them that I will argue is undervalued. And is still at the heart (hint hint) of some ongoing research…

 First described by Potain in 1880, the gallop rhythm refers to the presence and cadence of abnormal diastolic cardiac sounds, namely S3 and S4.
In 1989, Stevenson and Perloff described the previously unestablished relationship between physical exam signs, increased ventricular filling pressures, and decreased cardiac output in chronic HF patients. Stevenson et al. JAMA. 1989. https://t.co/Fjpx1MQLTX
An excellent point is made in this paper: “While the relationship between physical signs and hemodynamic profile has a firm basis for acute congestive heart failure, the chronic state is characterized by a host of compensatory mechanisms that may cause disparities, …”
“…such as the absence of rales and peripheral edema despite symptomatic elevation of ventricular filling pressures.”

This cohort had quite the notable med regimen: digoxin (84%), furosemide (84%), vasodilators (56%), and milrinone (4%); 39/50 were being evaluated for transplant
Interestingly, S3 was not specific for identifying high filling pressures in this cohort – possibly given that it was graded on a binary scale (presence vs. absence). Could it be more useful if somehow represented as a continuous variable??
Similarly, presence of rales was non-specific, only found in 19% of patients with PCWP > 22.

A plausible explanation for this observation in chronic (as opposed to acute HF):
In chronic HF - a sudden elevation of pulmonary venous pressure causes rales due to extravasation of fluid into the alveoli, but chronic exudation of fluid is associated with an increase in lymphatic drainage so that the alveoli remain relatively dry and rales are absent.
Last, elevated JVP correlated tightly with other physical signs of congestion but was not particularly specific for detection of elevated filling pressures.
Taken together, this study suggested that marked to severe elevations of left ventricular filling pressure frequently are undetected and recommend more judicious use of invasive hemodynamic monitoring in this population.
Over a decade later, the prognostic value of the third heart sound and elevated JVP was further explored by Drazner et al. (NEJM, 2001), in a retrospective analysis of 2569 HF patients enrolled in the SOLVD trial (enalapril vs placebo for HFrEF).
https://t.co/UKT9XDf0mc
On univariate analysis, patients with an S3 were at significantly higher risk of death from all causes (RR 1.35 [1.17-1.55], P<0.001) and hospitalization for heart failure (RR 1.70 [1.46-1.97], P<0.001) than those without an S3.
A strength of this study was the addition of multivariate analysis to adjust for markers of HF severity (LVEF, NYHA class, medications, serum Na, etc). Contrary to what was seen in other observational studies (such as above), S3 and elevated JVP had a strong prognostic value.
In summary, presence of S3 and elevated JVP was associated with subsequent HF hospitalization, increased risk of HF progression and all-cause mortality. An association that persisted even with adjustment for markers of disease severity.
One may ask whether there is a “better” or more objective/standardized way to assess these signs, namely S3. Marcus et al. (JAMA. 2005) aimed to test this using phonocardiographic measurements to detect abnormal LV function.
https://t.co/xWeIhzZ93b
Neither the device-measured S3 nor the S4 was a sensitive marker of left ventricular dysfunction, however, phonocardiographic S3 is specific for left ventricular dysfunction and appears to be superior to the moderate specificity of the S4.
Moving forward now – we have shown that certain parameters are good prognostic factors for HF, based on how they tie into the pathophysiology of HF itself. Can we add additional measures with high clinical relevance to create a model for prediction of impending HF exacerbation?
The above parameters form the HeartLogic Index used in the MultiSENSE trial - incorporated into ICD/CRT-Ds allowing for automated daily HF status eval and early awareness of impending decompensation with high sensitivity of 70% (Boehmer, JACC:HF, 2017) https://t.co/6IWfheQhdd
This algorithm was designed to detect gradual worsening of HF over days to weeks. The median early warning (alert window) was 34 days before a heart failure event, which is critical in order to provide actionable care to a patient early in the decompensation spectrum.
Further analysis of MultiSENSE (Gardner, Circ HF, 2018) showed the risk of a heart failure event while “in-alert” was 10x higher then when “out of alert” by HeartLogic Index (0.80 vs 0.08/pt-year)
https://t.co/Plaev6fe4q
What about biomarkers?
Substratification showed that the lowest risk group (low NT-proBNP and not in alert status) vs. the highest risk group (high NT-proBNP levels and being in alert status), had a 50-fold increased risk of an HF event (1.00/pt-year vs 0.02/pt-year).
Although NT-proBNP levels had independent predictive power for HF events, it was significantly lower than that of the HeartLogic alert algorithm alone (event rates: 0.42 vs 0.80/pt-year).
Furthermore, the risk for a HF event was greater in patients with low NT-proBNP levels but in HeartLogic alert status than in subjects with high NT-proBNP levels but out of device alert status (event rates: 0.47 vs 0.16/pt-year).
If you made it this far, you must also love heart failure remote monitoring (!!)

Look how far we’ve come from simply placing a stethoscope on a patient - although this is still not obsolete, it has led to some excellent advances over the years.
Next, we will look at some other monitoring systems – implantable hemodynamic sensors along with wearable monitoring (a taste below). And discuss some the recent work in the field, and where things may go in the future. Until next time.
https://t.co/6jyS3lhfE5
Some folks who might like this: @JeffHsuMD @FudimMarat @DrNasrien @JJheart_doc @AndrewJSauer @RyanTedfordMD @JagSinghMD @MarkDrazner @NMHheartdoc @gcfmd @HFpEF @Cardiobro @TJHeartFellows @HanCardiomd @JavedButler1 @JonathanDavisHF @MKIttlesonMD @DavidLBrownMD @CMichaelGibson etc
And our recent review article on this topic:
Ali, O., Hajduczok, A.G. & Boehmer, J.P. Remote Physiologic Monitoring for Heart Failure. Curr Cardiol Rep 22, 68 (2020).
https://t.co/1bmFVDU4Ij

More from Health

Gregg Gonsalves
Gregg Gonsalves
@gregggonsalves
Eight years ago, Spencer Cox died of #AIDS. He had access to #antiretroviral therapy, but in his own struggles with #depression and substance use, he stopped taking them. 1/

Spencer left college, dropped out like me in the 80s, and we both found ourselves in @actupny where we joined the Treatment and Data Committee, doing battle with drug companies, the @US_FDA, the @NIH on a quest to save ourselves and our friends from near-certain death. 2/

Now everyone knows what those dark days before the advent of antiretroviral therapy were like. Waves upon waves of dying friends. A government who couldn't care less for the sick and dying. 3/

All this has happened before, and all this will happen again. AIDS. #COVID19. The next pandemic. The fire next time. 4/

And it changes you. Seeing so much death so young. Seeing those in power turn away from the catastrophe, even joke about it (find, listen to the tape of Larry Speakes in Oval Office w Reagan laughing about AIDS). 5/
HEALTH
Buku Renal
Buku Renal
@BukuRenal
“Should I give them more fluid?”

Extremely common question during AKI referrals from junior docs.

⛔️ Fluid management is tricky, often misunderstood, & can cause huge iatrogenic harm ⛔️

We try to convey important principles in THREAD 👇

#tipsfornewdocs #medtwitter #tweetorial

Currently too often patients with high creatinine are given too much IV fluid, driven by an AKI ➡️ fluid reflex

We’ve seen 7 litres be given in one shift.

Medics & surgeons, juniors & seniors, it seems everyone loves to reach for extra IV fluid (especially if urine output poor)

Why does huge volume IV fluid ‘resuscitation’ consistently occur?

Lots of reasons, including FALSE beliefs:
🛑 IV fluid always “treats AKI”
🛑 Hypotension = hypovolaemia
🛑 Lactate >2 means fluid deficiency
🛑 Septic patients are very hypovolaemic

The rule with IV fluids and AKI is to remember this 5 word phrase:

💥 💥 Aim for euvolaemia, then stop💥 💥

Fluid status is like Goldilocks - hypovolaemia is bad for the kidneys BUT excess volume is also harmful for renal function and will cause other complications too.

It is easy to say “target euvolaemia” - but we agree it is more difficult to do!

Fluid status assessment is certainly made harder by a belief that we must only rely on a snapshot assessment of examination features which are NOT specific / sensitive / reliable to elicit like.…
HEALTH
Advertisement
Patrick Strudwick
Patrick Strudwick
@PatrickStrud
I’m deeply saddened to learn that Dr Joseph Sonnabend, one of the most important figures in the history of AIDS, died yesterday. I spent time with him in 2018 for one of the last interviews he ever gave. Let me tell you about this man and what he did:

Sonnabend was one of the first doctors to raise the alarm. In 1979, while running a sexual health clinic in Greenwich Village, he wrote to the NY Health Dept to warn them of the symptoms he was seeing: low white blood cell counts, enlarged lymph nodes. He didn’t get a reply. 2/

So he kept speaking out. When a patient of his developed a very rare cancer – Kaposi’s Sarcoma – he linked up with a dermatologist at NYU who said that over a dozen gay men had it. Sonnabend knew there was something very wrong. He started working at the lab at NYU — for free. 3/

It was soon after this in 1981 that the New York Times famously reported “Rare Cancer Found In 41 Homosexuals”. The next decade would kill most of Sonnabend’s patients and friends — and all of his lovers. What Sonnabend did was to fight for every single of them. 4/

Want to know who was the first to publish advice to wear a condom? That was Sonnabend. In 1983 he co-authored the first safe sex leaflet to fight AIDS: “How To Have Sex In An Epidemic”. 5/
HEALTH
writer sam
writer sam
@writersamr
Some thoughts on this: Firstly, it might be personal preference, but I am not keen on this kind of campaign as I feel like it trivialises cancer. Sometimes the serious message gets lost because people are sharing pics of cats or whatever and the important context is gone.


More importantly, the statistic being used in the campaign is misleading. It says 57% of women put off cervical screening if they can't get waxed. But on further investigation, that's not accurate.

The page here goes on to say "57% of women who regularly have their pubic hair professionally removed would put off attending their cervical screening appointment if they hadn’t been able to visit a beauty salon."

So the 57% represents a concern not across the whole population of women, but only those who regularly get waxed. So how big of an issue is this across the whole population? And what else is stopping people getting smears?

I think campaigns for cancer screening are really tricky because there is so much nuance that often doesn't fit into a catchy headline or hashtag. It's certainly not easy and is part of a bigger conversation.
HEALTH
AutisticSciencePerson
AutisticSciencePerson
@AutSciPerson
Okay, let's start this hypersomnia thread!

[note - I am not looking for unsolicited advice.]

Idiopathic hypersomnia or narcolepsy (not the same, but similar) is very hard to describe to people.

When I say "I slept 10 hours last night and I'm still tired" I'm not bragging. 1/16

For me, the accommodations I need are about time. My body doesn't care what I want to do - when I want to wake up or be asleep. My body wants to wake up at 10-11am, and go to sleep at 3am, always.

Just a one hour shift in my sleep schedule can screw me up for days. 2/16

When I tell people that I'd really "prefer it" if we could meet at 10am or later, it's because getting up before that has consequences for me. Big consequences. Most people won't see them. Sometimes I still give in and say it's fine. It ruins 2-3 of my days, sometimes more. 3/16

Let me explain. When I am required to wake up at 9am, esp. in covid times working from home, my body pays me back for it later.

I'm going to show you ways this happens. I can usually withstand 1 day of waking up early, with some consequences, but 2 days in a row kills me. 4/16

Let's say this graph represents Day 1, the first time I am required to get up early. The y-axis is my level of Sleepiness. Any symptom listed higher up includes that symptom + every other symptom below it. Getting up that early means I can't listen or concentrate all day. 5/16
HEALTH

You May Also Like

Hector Navarro
Hector Navarro
@Hectorisfunny
I'm going to attempt to chronologically list all of the Marvel characters Stan Lee had a hand in creating. Working with his genius collaborators, Stan and his team produced an insane amount of iconic characters in a roughy ten year period. (Thread)


With his younger brother, writer Larry Lieber, and Jack "the King" Kirby:

Groot

Tales to Astonish #13 (November, 1960)


With writer Lieber, and artist Kirby:

Fin Fang Foom

Strange Tales #89 (October, 1961)


With the King, Stan gives birth to the Marvel Universe:

The Fantastic Four

Fantastic Four #1 (November, 1961)


With Jack Kirby:

Mister Fantastic

Fantastic Four #1 (November, 1961)
CULTURE
Buzz Chronicles
Buzz Chronicles
@buzz_chronicles
@SaveToBookmarks Namaste! You can find it here. Original tweet by @AchuthArora: "@OllieEmberson @buzz_chronicles @rattibha @SaveToBookmarks save as Workouts". Thanks! ✌

Hi! Pleasure is mine. Original tweet by @SaveToBookmarks: "@AchuthArora @OllieEmberson @buzz_chronicles @rattibha Cool mate!

I saved this ...". See You soon! 👌
ALL
Advertisement
Naval
Naval
@naval
How to Get Rich (without getting lucky):

Seek wealth, not money or status. Wealth is having assets that earn while you sleep. Money is how we transfer time and wealth. Status is your place in the social hierarchy.

Understand that ethical wealth creation is possible. If you secretly despise wealth, it will elude you.

Ignore people playing status games. They gain status by attacking people playing wealth creation games.

You’re not going to get rich renting out your time. You must own equity - a piece of a business - to gain your financial freedom.
LIFE , STARTUPS , NAVAL1
Jijo Sunny
Jijo Sunny
@JijoSunny
1/ 👋 Excited to share what we’ve been building at https://t.co/GOQJ7LjQ2t + we are going to tweetstorm our progress every week!

Week 1 highlights: getting shortlisted for YC W2019🤞, acquiring a premium domain💰, meeting Substack's @hamishmckenzie and Stripe CEO @patrickc 🤩

2/ So what is Brew?

brew / bru : / to make (beer, coffee etc.) / verb: begin to develop 🌱

A place for you to enjoy premium content while supporting your favorite creators. Sort of like a ‘Consumer-facing Patreon’ cc @jackconte

(we’re still working on the pitch)

3/ So, why be so transparent? Two words: launch strategy.

jk 😅 a) I loooove doing something consistently for a long period of time b) limited downside and infinite upside (feedback, accountability, reach).
cc @altimor, @pmarca


4/ https://t.co/GOQJ7LjQ2t domain 🍻

It started with a cold email. Guess what? He was using BuyMeACoffee on his blog, and was excited to hear about what we're building next. Within 2w, we signed the deal at @Escrowcom's SF office. You’re a pleasure to work with @MichaelCyger!

5/ @ycombinator's invite for the in-person interview arrived that evening. Quite a day!

Thanks @patio11 for the thoughtful feedback on our YC application, and @gabhubert for your directions on positioning the product — set the tone for our pitch!
TECH
Simon Wardley #EEA
Simon Wardley #EEA
@swardley
X : Our executive team is concerned that we need to up our game in order to out innovate Amazon.
Me : Do you map?
X : Yes
Me : Like this?
X : No. What's that?
Me : A map of a tea shop.


X : Why is that a map?
Me : Long story, all to do with how space has meaning. To keep it short, maps help people to focus on user needs, the components involved, to communicate missing components and scenario play ideas like staff becoming robots.


Me : They’re also good for measuring and managing capital flow, making investment decisions, removing bias and getting rid of duplication.
X : I don’t see how that helps with innovation?


Me : Well, innovation is a tricky word because we use it to describe many things. If you’re talking about differentiation with the adjacent unexplored then you’re experimenting in the “uncharted” space e.g. immortality with magic provided by the special custom built kettle.


X : That sounds like nonsense.
Me : A lot of what people think will be the next great innovation is nonsense. Actually, most of it is. That’s the nature of the uncharted space, it’s experimental, high risk and generally results in failure.
X : We need more reliable innovation.
TECH