BC WORLD
Saved by @WebbDarrrel

NS2 a response to Mr Wolfgang Munchau. Although I agree on a number of points with WM in his recent @spectator piece-I disagree with his central contention that NS2 is about more gas for Germany. There is no more gas & what gas there is not for Germany. Lengthy thread to follow.

 1.WMs @EuroBriefing article has swallowed a huge dose of Russian (and indeed German) propaganda. Throughout the article WM refers to Nord Stream 2 as being vital to Germany because of the need for more Russian gas. This is incorrect.https://t.co/hua0IAYo6N
2.The key point about NS2 is that it is a diversionary pipeline. There is no new gas. This huge political effort by Russia and Germany to deliver NS2 will not bring a single extra molecule of gas to Germany.
3.What is more the gas destined to land on the German Baltic coast at Greifswald (in AM's constituency) will substantially go not to Germany. The connecting pipeline for NS2, called EUGAL has the same capacity as NS2 (55bcm) and heads eastward to the Czech Republic.
4.Our friendly gas propagandists may well say that in December 2019 Gazprom signed a gas transit contract with the Ukrainian state owned energy company Naftogaz for 40bcm a year from 2021-2024. So with NS2 there will be more gas. NS2 plus the gas transited via Ukraine.
5.The problem with that argument is that the reason that the December 2019 contract was signed was because the US had imposed sanctions meaning that NS2 could not be completed in time to replace the Ukrainian transit route. Moscow then had no other option.
6. As soon as NS2 is operating Moscow will either take the Turkmenistan option ie blowing up part of the Ukrainian network & claim force majeure (as they did in 2009) or the arbitration option. Just stop transit and let Kyiv sue (you may be able to seize assets in 10 years).
7.Its worth looking at why Moscow wants NS2. First, it’s a plunder project. As explained in the Sberbank Report Russian Oil and Gas: Tickling Giants (google it) the principal motivator for projects such as NS2 is for the elites close to power to plunder energy firms
8. Second is the Ukrainian issue. Its network is the world’s largest gas transit and storage system. It has 140bcm of transit and 32 bcm of storage capacity. It is a pillar of European supply security, supply can be ramped up whenever required far beyond the capacity of NS2.
9. Yet, if as the Russians intend gas supply across the Ukrainian network is reduced to zero, capacity will be lost as the pipelines deteriorate. If NS2 goes ahead this pillar of European supply security will be lost as the Ukrainian network goes offline.
10. This takes us to the second underlying Russian reason for NS2: To undermine Ukraine. The aim is to undermine Ukrainian supply security, make it more dependent on Moscow and strip it of the gas transit fees.
11. And Moscow hopes with Ukraine being less vital to EU energy security, Ukrainian independence can be extinguished in darkness and with silence from Brussels & Berlin.
12. The third reason is not just to undermine Ukrainian independence but to also undermine the independence of states across Central & Eastern Europe. Over the last 15 years CEE states have been increasingly connected to the Western European gas market. NS2 aims to reverse this.
13. NS2 will flood the west to east interconnectors blocking competing gas entering the region. In addition currently CE Europe has a degree of transit security flowing from the reality that Russian gas transiting through CE Europe flows on to Western Europe. This is lost withNS2
14. This latter fear is why Poland has taken a number of steps to protect its own supply security by bringing on stream the Baltic Pipeline with 10bcm of capacity and upgrading & expanding its LNG facilities, so it can ship in LNG from global markets as an alternative to Rus gas.
15. None of the Russian reasons for pushing NS2 involve the actual supply of extra gas for Germany. There is no extra gas, and most of the gas in the NS2 pipeline is not actually for Germany.
16. WM is correct that Germany energy policy is a disaster whether one considers the cost or the result. Berlin has managed to deliver a policy which is very expensive and increases C02 emissions.
17. Germany has ended up with a wind, coal, coal strategy, whilst talking green. However, while Berlin also talks about gas there is actually no new gas supplies being delivered to deal with the closure of nuclear power stations. Probably Berlin will end up using yet more coal.
18. Why then does Berlin support NS2? There are several. First misplaced guilt. The terrible things that Nazi Germany in the USSR. However, as Timothy Snyder indicates in his 2017 great lecture this is a story of significantly misplaced guilt https://t.co/2lwKCR2XSj
19. The greatest force of Nazi atrocities were borne by the Ukrainians. Not the Russians. If Berlin is going to have its external policies affected by guilt they should surely be at least affected by what was done to Ukraine as what was done to Russia.
20. Second, there is the myth of ‘the riches of the east’ for German business. This myth has been going on since the days of Catherine the Great. It is mythical. Germany exports more to the Poland, Czech Republic & Hungary (individually) than it does to Russia.
21. The third & more real advantage is energy acreage. This is a real goal of some Western energy companies. To gain energy acreage in Siberia. Energy acreage does not just add to profits it also flatters the balance sheet. NS2 is a reasonable exchange for energy acreage.
22. WM in fact underplays the extent to which NS2 is a geostrategic disaster for Germany. Not only have there now been four European Parliament resolutions against NS2, legislation has been enacted that will make it difficult to ever operate NS2 as Gazprom intended.
23. In February 2019 the EP and the EU Council over German objections (ie Germany was not able to find enough states to even deliver a blocking minority to a QMV) formally extended the gas directive 2009 to import pipelines.
24. This legislation applies the full force of EU liberalisation law to NS2. The pipeline will have to be unbundled, will require transparent tariff regulation and third-party access. It will also require a supply security risk assessment as NS2 is a non-EU owned pipeline.
25. As a consequence even if US sanctions do not succeed the pipeline will face a formidable legal battle to become operational on the terms that Gazprom would demand. The EU Gen. Court in the OPAL case has already sided with Poland over the operation of NS1’s connecting pipeline
26. Poland and other EU states will be able to use their rights to bring the EU legal issues directly to Luxembourg to challenge the operation of NS2. The EU General Court in OPAL already has given an expansive interpretation to the principle of energy solidarity in the EUTreaty
27. For Germany therefore faces not only a huge operation to attempt to defang US sanctions, it also faces a second major battle within the EU to prevail under Union law-where frankly the chances of success are low.
28. Geostrategically the consequences of NS2 are highly significant. First, Germany has burnt through an enormous amount of trust across the EU in pushing the pipeline. Not just in CE Europe or Scandinavia.
29. It is an open question who has burnt through more trust in the EU, Germany over NS2, Britain over Brexit? The Brits may be crazy and ideological but they are at least not working hand in hand with a hostile power against the security interests of EU Member States
30. Second, German support for NS2 undermines the concept of European strategic autonomy. The response of CE Europe is to strengthen its own energy and military security as Poland has done, and bind itself tightly to the United States.
31. Whatever honeyed words come from Berlin or Brussels about ‘strategic autonomy’ are going to fall on stony ground in many EU capitals. How can there be any EU strategic autonomy when Berlin is so directly willing to undermine and abandon the security issues of other EU states?
32. From a US perspective it can take considerable degree of comfort in the overwhelming support of the EP and EU Member States to proceed to implement sanctions in full against NS2. Opposition to sanctions is German. It is not European.
33. The US could also legitimately look at a wider range of sanctions, including on Western energy companies who have profited at above market rates from what essentially is a plunder operation by elites close to the Kremlin.
34. NS2 should be stopped, it is a huge security risk to the EU and Ukraine. And if that requires a raft of additional sanctions from Washington, so be it.
35. For the Brits there are questions. The first is-where have you been? Brexit has been so all encompassing that HMG has been largely absent from the field on a key security issues to its allies in NATO both across the Channel and across the Atlantic. HMG needs to get engaged.
36. Second, in terms of engagement, HMG can clearly support US sanctions. HMG could also play a significant role in CE Europe and Ukraine, developing a more proactive energy strategy which would undermine the energy leverage game played by Moscow over the last two decades.
37. Thirdly, and finally, as the NS2 debacle undermines the case for EU strategic autonomy, it does open up a greater opportunity for London to work with EU States in developing mechanisms to enhance European security-as Brexit or no, we continue to share the same continent/ End

More from World

Mencius Moldbugman
Mencius Moldbugman
@moldbugman
There is a recent new word in Chinese that I think deserves introducing into the Western neoreactionary canon.

The word is 内卷 (nei-juan) which has been translated as "involution". Originally a Chinese phenomenon it increasingly applies anywhere there is modernity.

To capture the essence of what "involution" means it helps to picture a spiral in your mind. Our modern narrative says that as we progress technologically we should progress OUT of the spiral and have more free time to be capable of ever more amazing things...


But what if the progression of technology and society actually sends us WITHIN the spiral in an infinite number of ever-decreasing circles? What if we are walking DOWN the spiral staircase of progress rather than UP?


"Involution" in its original meaning has been used to describe agrarian societies and how their development actually leads to self-perpetuating processes that prevent change and progress rather than encourage it.

Increased food production has limited many civilisations and sent them into stagnancy rather than allowed them to grow. This stagnancy can continue for millennia in safe environments till threatened, other times it drives the civilisation into extinction from external threats.
WORLD
Dr Mahathir Mohamad
Dr Mahathir Mohamad
@chedetofficial
MISREPRESENTED CONTEXT

1. I am indeed disgusted with attempts to misrepresent and take out of context what I wrote on my blog yesterday.


2. Those who did that highlighted only one part of paragraph 12 which read: “Muslims have a right to be angry and to kill millions of French people for the massacres of the past.”

3. They stopped there and implied that I am promoting the massacre of the French.

4.If they had read d posting in its entirety & especially the subsequent sentence which read: “But by & large the Muslims hv not applied the “eye for an eye” law. Muslims don’t. The French shouldn’t. Instead the French should teach their people to respect other people’s feelings

5. Because of the spin and out of context presentation by those that picked up my posting, reports were made against me and I am accused of promoting violence etc… on Facebook and Twitter.
WORLD
Advertisement
Gina Bates
Gina Bates
@hilltopgina
Why I am disgusted by the human species.

Speciesism Part 2: Marine Life

It is estimated that up to 3 trillion fish are caught from the wild & killed globally every year: This doesn’t include the billions of fish that are farmed. Fish account for 40% of animal products consumed


Fish farming is forecast to overtake wild-caught fish production in 2021: For context, farmed fish accounts for 70% of all farmed animals worldwide. This presents a host of problems. For example, shrimp farming has led to the destruction of three million acres of coastal wetlands


Like all captivity of sentient life fish farming is creating disease. This ends up in the wider ecosystem damaging and polluting wildlife.


Worldwide demand for seafood is expected to double in the next two decades A recent global survey in has estimated that we could see sea life vanish altogether by 2048. Due to the relentless fishing and relentless pollution. The corals are dying.


Whales:

Despite a moratorium on commercial whaling and a ban on international trade of whale products, three countries-Iceland, Japan, and Norway—continue their commercial whale hunts.
16,000 whales have been murdered every year for 83 consecutive years.
WORLD
Frontier Indica
Frontier Indica
@frontierindica
In what was United Bengal (modern day West Bengal+Bangladesh) back in 1941, Muslims were 56% of the population, and today they are approximately about 67% of the population. If you go back to the early 20th century or the late 19th century, Muslims weren't even a majority.

This

example of Bengal is what has been happening across the whole of the Indian sub-continent, albeit at a slower or faster pace as the case may be region to region, but the fact remains that the change has been unidirectional= As time goes by, the proportion of Muslims increases in

a given region and the proportion of Hindus goes down. Project the numbers out into 50 or 60 years and you have multiple states/regions of India with a Muslim plurality or outright majority. Project the numbers out to a century or so and it's difficult to argue how Hindus can

maintain cultural/political dominance in the long run. Some people like to say, "Oh well so what. Numbers don't matter, what have you achieved at 80% of the population which you're going to achieve at 90%!".

This is faulty thinking, because the direction of change itself is

the demgoraphic sense is quite critical of whether you are expanding or retreating civilisation. The more people you have relative to the enemy, the more the chances that you will adamant about taking over more territory. The less people you have relative to the enemy, the more
WORLD
Gulay Turkmen
Gulay Turkmen
@gulayturkmen
Watch the entire discussion if you have the time to do so. But if not, please make sure to watch Edhem Eldem summarizing ~150 years of democracy in Turkey in 6 minutes (starting on 57'). And if you can't watch it, fear not; I've transcribed it for you (as public service). Thread:


"Let me start by saying that I am a historian, I see dead people. But more seriously, I am constantly torn between the temptation to see patterns developing over time, and the fear of hasty generalizations and anachronistic comparisons. 1/n

"Nevertheless, the present situation forces me to explore the possible historical dimensions of the problem we're facing today. 2/n

"(...)I intend to go further back in time and widen the angle in order to focus on the confusion I  believe exists between the notions of 'state', 'government', and 'public institutions' in Turkey. 3/n

"In the summer of 1876, that's a historical quote, as Midhat Pasa was trying to draft a constitution, Edhem Pasa wrote to Saffet Pasa, and I quote in Turkish, 'Bize Konstitusyon degil enstitusyon lazim' ('It is not a constitution we need but institutions'). 4/n
WORLD

You May Also Like

Roger Grosse
Roger Grosse
@RogerGrosse
Important paper from Google on large batch optimization. They do impressively careful experiments measuring # iterations needed to achieve target validation error at various batch sizes. The main "surprise" is the lack of surprises. [thread]

https://t.co/7QIx5CFdfJ


The paper is a good example of lots of elements of good experimental design. They validate their metric by showing lots of variants give consistent results. They tune hyperparamters separately for each condition, check that optimum isn't at the endpoints, and measure sensitivity.

They have separate experiments where the hold fixed # iterations and # epochs, which (as they explain) measure very different things. They avoid confounds, such as batch norm's artificial dependence between batch size and regularization strength.

When the experiments are done carefully enough, the results are remarkably consistent between different datasets and architectures. Qualitatively, MNIST behaves just like ImageNet.

Importantly, they don't find any evidence for a "sharp/flat optima" effect whereby better optimization leads to worse final results. They have a good discussion of experimental artifacts/confounds in past papers where such effects were reported.
MACHINE LEARNING
Mystery Grove Publishing Co.
Mystery Grove Publishi...
@MysteryGrove
By popular demand, here is the official Mystery Grove Film Recommendations list. Watch all of these in order if you want to truly understand the world we live in today.
CULTURE
Advertisement
Vibhu Vashisth
Vibhu Vashisth
@VIBHU_Tweet
LACHIT BORPHUKAN : AN UNSUNG WARRIOR OF THE AHOM KINGDOM & THE GREAT BATTLE OF SARAIGHAT

Originally named as Lachit Deca, Lachit Borphukan, the fierce and invincible Ahom Commander, was born during the early 17th century at Betioni in the Golaghat district of modern Assam.


His father, Momai Tamuli Borbarua was the ‘Governor’ of the kingdom and also ‘Commander-in-Chief’ of Ahom army under King Pratap Singha during his reign starting from 1603 to 1639. Lachit received military training from an early age and joined the Ahom King Jayadhvaj Singha...


...(1648-1663) as a scarf-bearer.  The post ‘scarf-bearer’ or ‘Soladhara Barua’ is considered as a part of the incumbent king’s personal staff. Owing to his military training Lechit was appointed "Ghora Barua", Supdt. of the Royal horses. When Chakradhwaj Singha became king..


..of Ahom dynasty in 1663,he appointed him Suptd. of The Royal Guards &finally he was appointed as Borphukan by the king.Then onwards,he was known as Lachit Borphukan.Borphukan used to be top councillor in Ahom Kingdom. This position was embedded with executive & judicial powers.


Assam was facing incessant Islamic invasion since Jan1662, when Mughal General Mir Jumla II attacked Ahom capital Gargaon. He never defeated Ahom king Jayadhwaja Singha as king retreated to hill &continued Guerrilla warfare.Prolonged fight &prospect of stalemate disturbed Jumla.
ALL
Justin Mikolay \U0001f4bb
Justin Mikolay 💻...
@jmikolay
A distillation of what @naval said on Clubhouse last night:

What you call chaos I call spontaneity.

A regimented life is like a heartbeat that's non-chaotic; it's a system that’s too ordered. It doesn't have any life to it. And real life has lots of ups and downs, some of them very extreme.

I over-plan, but planning is pretty useless. What tends to dominant life are a small number of Black Swan events in both directions, positive and negative.

Expose yourself to asymmetric upside and lots of good options: things that can become massively important for you.

And you want to avoid the asymmetric downside: anything that can end the game, whether it's through financial ruin, or reputational ruin, or physical ruin.

That requires a certain amount of chaos and spontaneity.

If nothing else, 2020 taught the power of optionality.

We think about planning as linear and controlled, but that's not how the world around us works anymore.

The world is dominated by nonlinearities, so understanding options value is far more important.
ALL , NAVAL , NAVAL HIGHLISHTS
sriram
sriram
@SriramKannan77
Swami Ramanujar:
Important personalities in Sri Ramanujas Life :
🌸ASURI KESHAVA SOMAYAJI-Father of Sri Ramanujar .Asuri keshava somayaji was a learned brahmana living in sriperumbudur.


🌸KANTHIMATHI-Mother of Sri Ramanuja. Kanthimathi was the sister of sri periya thirumalai nambi .
🌸SRI YAMUNACHARYA-Acharya of Sri Ramanuja.Also known as Alavandar.
🌸THIRUKOKOSHTIYUR NAMBI-Also known as Ghosti Purna.He instructed the Rahasya Traya to Sri Ramanujar.

He lived in thirukoshtiyur.
🌸THIRUKKACHI NAMBI-Kanchi purna was born in puvirunthavalli near kanchipuram and met the young ramanuja at an important time.He did the service of Lord Varadha.

🌸THIRUVARANGA PERUMAL ARAIYAR-Important acharya lived in srirangam and rendered the service of playing music for lord Sriranganatha.

🌸PERIYA THIRUMALAI NAMBI-He was the maternal uncle of Sri Ramanuja.He taught sri ramanuja about the epic of sri ramayana and other ithihaas and puranas.Served sri venkateswara at tirumala.
ALL